White Columns Online #38:
Clothes, not Fashion
curated by Gemma Cirignano

Noah Pica
Business trip, 2023
Uniqlo cotton shirt with plastic and wrapping tissue intact, grommets, wheels, screws, nuts
13 1/2 × 11 1/2 × 4 1/2 in.

Alice Wu
Yellowstone, 2024
cotton, rayon, wool, kapok, fabric remnants, wood, sand, plastics, acrylic
14 × 10 × 5 in.

Hatty Buchanan
LISTEN FOR THE GLITCH /, 2025
textile, mixed media
41 × 23 1/2 in.

Ido Randon
Sail or Temporary composition of a specter of a world, 2023
deconstructed MOLLE backpacks, ripstop nylon, webbing, cord
138 × 47 × 2 in.

Betty Beaumont
LANDFILL BOUND with WORDS MATTER. PINK (WALL INSTALLATION) Untitled, 2022 (miscellaneous thrift shop clothing in foreground) child’s pink satin hanger with clips (fabric, foam rubber, ribbon, wood, metal), paper, ink, plastic, glass, metal
17 × 252 × 1 1/4 in. + 48 × 144 in. in diameter

Lu Heintz
Pockets, 2014
cast dryer lint
wall installation
72 × 144 in.

Noah Pica
Sleepy boy, 2022
cotton, wool, air mattress, bread bag clip
36 × 43 × 26 in.

Claire Watson
The Sames, 2025
collars of leather coats, thread, canvas, gesso
72 × 72 in.

Betty Beaumont
PRET-A-PORTER, 2019
rolling double clothes rack: chrome tubing, rubber wheels, hardware, plastic; wire hangers, paper tags, ink, shopping bags: paper, ink, fabric cord
57 1/2 × 60 × 44 in.

Hatty Buchanan
After Cutting, 2024
mixed media
51 × 40 in.

Kathleen King
Heterotopian Enclosure, 2019
discarded wood, housepaint, discarded clothing
65 × 42 × 37 in.

Lu Heintz
Sleeve #1, 2024
canvas, silk, rayon, batting, wood, steel
7 × 18 × 4 in.

Claire Watson
Don’t Mention It, 2026
pattern parts and other remnants of leather clothing, thread, canvas, gesso
72 × 72 in.

Kathleen King
22 Arists’ Belts, 2017
belts collected from members of an artists’ collective, nails, string
84 × 33 × 2 in.

Pol Morton
The Pants, 2026
hospital pants, insulation foam, fiberglass, aqua resin, acrylic mediums
55 × 45 × 3 in.
Curatorial Statement
“How can a product that needs to be sown, grown, harvested, combed, spun, knitted, cut and stitched, finished, printed, labeled, packaged and transported cost a couple of euros?” – Lidewij Edelkoort, Anti-Fashion Manifesto, 2014
Clothes, not fashion
Today’s fast fashion captures, packages, and sells a promise of individuality through algorithm-driven, factory-produced simulacra of style. Dupe culture, powered by AI that steals artists’ emerging designs and mass produces lower-cost replicas, makes self-expression through personal style increasingly difficult to cultivate. Clothing corporations strip the ideology and craftsmanship from their source material (handmade, sustainably-sourced, minority-owned…) and regurgitate a synthetic, factory-made version. Through strategic digital marketing, paid partnerships, and impossibly low prices, they supply online shoppers with duplicitous duplicative garments that destabilize signifiers of authenticity and promote single-use clothing at a rapid rate.
In his 1967 analysis of French fashion magazines, The Fashion System, semiologist Roland Barthes argues that each article of clothing contains three garments: real clothing (the physical object and its invisible labor), image-clothing (the photograph or illustration), and written clothing (the description). While today’s digital fashion media landscape has ballooned from the fashion magazines of the 1960s to 30-second TikToks and AI-generated outfit recommendations, Barthes’ tripartite rhetoric of fashion–technological, iconic, and verbal–serves as a useful framework for examining how meaning circulates through garments in an era of algorithmic reproduction. Building upon Barthes’ rhetoric of fashion, the artists in Clothes, not fashion, Betty Beaumont, Hatty Buchanan, Lu Heintz, Kathleen King, Pol Morton, Noah Pica, Ido Radon, Claire Watson, and Alice Wu, explore identity, waste, labor, and exploitation through the recuperation of real clothing, the reimagination of image-clothing, and the reinterpretation of written clothing.
Trend forecaster Lidewij Edelkoort makes a poignant semiotic distinction between clothes and fashion in her 2014 Anti-Fashion Manifesto, from which this exhibition borrows its title. In her manifesto, Edelkoort calls for a dissolution of the increasingly unsustainable fashion industry, which favors the spectacle and glamour of image and written clothing over the craft and labor of real clothing. The artist Lu Heintz’s ongoing series, not clothes, negates the existence of even real clothing to investigate what slippage takes place when functional and social meanings are severed from an article of clothing. In their soft sculpture Sleeve #1 (2024), the artist cuts, layers, restitches, stuffs, and mounts a salmon pink oxford shirt sleeve with a silk ruffle trim onto an aluminum shelf. The fleshy hue and soft, organic shape, while not wearable, maintains the identifiable elements of a shirt’s sleeve in the preservation of a buttoned cuff and an elongated forearm.
Artist and designer Noah Pica also uses an oxford shirt to critically examine the uniform as a site where heteronormativity is both inscribed and contested. In Business Trip (2023), Pica screws wheels onto a neatly folded blue oxford button-down. This basket-woven cotton shirt originated in late 19th century Scotland, was popularized by British polo players in the early twentieth century, and soon after, made its way into the American fashion lexicon of businessmen, politicians (famously President John F. Kennedy), and preparatory school students. Although its popularity grew out of an innocuous utilitarian practicality (breathable yet durable, soft yet structured) the oxford shirt endures as a signifier of assimilation into capitalism’s aptly named “white-collar” economy.
In 2013, the trend forecasting collective K-HOLE introduced “normcore,” a sociological attitude they coined to liberate basic garments, like the oxford shirt, from their normative signification. Coinciding with the rise of Instagram, however, influencers and their sponsoring brands have used the past decade to capitalize on -core’s infectious irony, introducing cottagecore, fairycore, angelcore, balletcore, Barbiecore, corpcore, bimbocore, mermaidcore, Europecore, gorpcore…and -core related aesthetics, tomato girl summer, clean girl, coquette, dark academia, indie sleaze, mob wife…The thinly veiled consumerist algorithm has emptied normcore of its original radicality, reducing it in the popular imagination to yet another micro-trend rather than the anti-trend it set out to be. In deconstructing and reassembling the oxford shirt as a sculptural object, Heintz and Pica resist a similar fate and force viewers to confront the real clothing’s labor, history, and physical presence, rather than its normative codes.
Predictably, the increase in trend cycles and decrease in product quality have led to an increase in textile waste, with the EPA recently estimating approximately 17 million tons of textile waste, predominantly from clothing, in 2018. The abundance of discarded garments itself has impacted consumer habits; thrifting and upcycling have shifted from a socioeconomic necessity to yet another trend and economy of clothing. Edelkoort remarks on these new consumers who “rent clothes, lend clothes, transform clothes and find clothes on the streets.” However, what is not accounted for is how poorly manufactured clothing will unravel this cyclical economy. When the sustainable, secondary market relies on well-crafted textile, what will the racks of Goodwill look like two generations into this micro-trend-filled system of planned obsolescence?
Artists Hatty Buchanan, Kathleen King, Claire Watson, and Alice Wu depend on pre-worn garments in their work. For her leather belt assemblage, 22 Artists’ Belts (2017), King asked every member of the artist-run gallery she participates in to contribute a belt, producing a singular work that meditates on collectivity and individuality within group dynamics. Suspended on a wall with undyed cotton string and nails, embossed, feathered, beaded, woven, and studded leather, plastic, and metal belts overlap yet maintain their unique character. Buchanan instead considers the personal and collective memories held in her second-hand garments, often drawn from childhood or the domestic sphere. Her patchwork textile (Sweet) Fanny Brown (2024), references Sweet Fanny Adams, a child brutally murdered in 1867 by a killer who was noted as well-dressed according to the artist. Unstitching, cutting, and re-suturing the Martin Margiela brown wool suiting skirt she sourced from a flea market, Buchanan evokes the pain and healing that follow violence.
The artists in Clothes, not fashion refuse the disposability logic of the hyper-consumptive fashion system. Through recuperating, reimagining, and reinterpreting real clothing, they ask their viewers to slow down and recognize clothing not as an algorithmic trend, duplicable design, or disposable commodity. In doing so, they embrace Edelkoort’s “clothes, not fashion,” not as cynicism of an obsolete industry, but as an emphasis on garments as the material witnesses to bodies, histories, and resistances.
Gemma Cirignano is a researcher and curator based in Brooklyn, New York. She received her B.A. in art history from the University of Vermont’s Honors College and her M.A. in art history from the Institute of Fine Arts at New York University. Her research centers on feminist and queer theories of artistic labor and materiality. She currently serves as the Curatorial Associate for Independent and has previously held positions at the Dia Art Foundation, Masterworks, Print Center New York, and Burlington City Arts. Cirignano has curated exhibitions at the Mobile Museum of Art, Level & Co. Gallery, and SPRING/BREAK, and has published her writing in the Woman’s Art Journal, Artefuse, Burntout Magazine, Irradicant, and Nat Mayer Shapiro: Joy and Rigor published by Silvana Editoriale.
Noah Pica
Business trip, 2023
Uniqlo cotton shirt with plastic and wrapping tissue intact, grommets, wheels, screws, nuts
13 1/2 × 11 1/2 × 4 1/2 in.
Alice Wu
Yellowstone, 2024
cotton, rayon, wool, kapok, fabric remnants, wood, sand, plastics, acrylic
14 × 10 × 5 in.
Hatty Buchanan
LISTEN FOR THE GLITCH /, 2025
textile, mixed media
41 × 23 1/2 in.
Ido Randon
Sail or Temporary composition of a specter of a world, 2023
deconstructed MOLLE backpacks, ripstop nylon, webbing, cord
138 × 47 × 2 in
Betty Beaumont
LANDFILL BOUND with WORDS MATTER. PINK (WALL INSTALLATION) Untitled, 2022 (miscellaneous thrift shop clothing in foreground) child’s pink satin hanger with clips (fabric, foam rubber, ribbon, wood, metal), paper, ink, plastic, glass, metal
17 × 252 × 1 1/4 in. + 48 × 144 in. in diameter
Lu Heintz
Pockets, 2014
cast dryer lint
wall installation
72 × 144 in.
Noah Pica
Sleepy boy, 2022
cotton, wool, air mattress, bread bag clip
36 × 43 × 26 in.
Claire Watson
The Sames, 2025
collars of leather coats, thread, canvas, gesso
72 × 72 in.
Betty Beaumont
PRET-A-PORTER, 2019
rolling double clothes rack: chrome tubing, rubber wheels, hardware, plastic; wire hangers, paper tags, ink, shopping bags: paper, ink, fabric cord
57 1/2 × 60 × 44 in.
Hatty Buchanan
After Cutting, 2024
mixed media
51 × 40 in.
Kathleen King
Heterotopian Enclosure, 2019
discarded wood, housepaint, discarded clothing
65 × 42 × 37 in.
Lu Heintz
Sleeve #1, 2024
canvas, silk, rayon, batting, wood, steel
7 × 18 × 4 in.
Claire Watson
Don’t Mention It, 2026
pattern parts and other remnants of leather clothing, thread, canvas, gesso
72 × 72 in.
Kathleen King
22 Arists’ Belts, 2017
belts collected from members of an artists’ collective, nails, string
84 × 33 × 2 in.
Pol Morton
The Pants, 2026
hospital pants, insulation foam, fiberglass, aqua resin, acrylic mediums
55 × 45 × 3 in.